Madison Historical Society logo

Madison Historical Society

Madison Mysteries!
The Merriman Monument

In the early 1990’s, a large rectangular-shaped headstone was found, unearthed while workers were constructing a new parking lot.  The lot, in what was then Penguin Mechanical Services (now Positive Energy Electrical) is at the northeast corner of Eagle Street and West Main Street, in Madison village.  Three sides of the stone bear the names of the Merriman family – Dr. A. Merriman, died July 23, 1867), Grata Merriman, wife of Dr. A. Merriman, dates illegible, and Kate C., daughter of Dr. A. And G.T. Merriman, February 23 1850, aged 3 years.  The fourth side lists three names – Irwin S. Childs 1840 – (blank), Ellen B. Merriman, his wife, 1842 – 1897, and Harry M. Childs, 1871 – 1894.  Naturally the question follows, who were these people, and why are they there?

Thanks to the Lake County Genealogical Society’s website, we know that a cemetery in Madison village was the Centreville Cemetery, Centreville/Centerville being the name of the village in the early 1800’s. General Abel Kimball, in his “General History of the Township” wrote in 1880 that Silas Newcomb sold to a group of ‘subscribers’ on Aug. 19, 1817, one-half acre and 28 rods of ground, ‘To be tenanted, improved and occupied and made use of as a burying ground or deposit for the dead, and may be occupied and made use of by all religious societies of the township of Madison.’ The lot was situated on the northwest corner of West Main and Eagle Streets. The Centreville cemetery served the village and township until 1854. According to Gen. Kimball, a cemetery association “was formed which purchased the site of the present Village Cemetery to which the bodies deposited in the former burying ground were removed.” The ‘new’ cemetery Kimball refers to is Fairview Memorial Park, on River Road in the village.

Childs Family

Based on Gen. Kimball’s writings, we know the bodies were removed from the West Main/Eagle Street cemetery. But what about the Merriman or Childs family? The Centreville cemetery was on the northwest side of Eagle Street, and the headstone found buried in the earth on the northeast side of the street. We know Kate Merriman was the only name on the headstone who died prior to the cemetery moving, and its bodies relocated. We also know that the Andrews, Grata, and Kate Merriman, and Ellen Merriman Childs and Harry Childs, all have a large family headstone, as well as individual headstones, in Fairview Memorial Park (section B3, row 1). Except for Kate, they all died after the Centreville Cemetery was relocated. Irwin and Ethel Childs divorced, and Irwin died in California in 1928. The likely conclusion is that there are no bodies in the parking lot at the intersection of West Main and Eagle streets. Why the ‘old’ stone was buried is open to speculation.

Fairview Cem. Merriman, Childs, Wheeler Monument

A final bit more information… There is a brass plaque on the ‘Kate’ side of the monument at West Main and Eagle streets, with the name of Louis C. Grabski, U.S. Navy Veteran, who served in WWII.  Mr. Grabski lived at 15 Eagle Street while growing up, and lived his life there until his death in 2001.  The Centreville Cemetery was said to have been located where the house at 15 Eagle Street stood, continuing about ¼ mile west behind the houses along West Main.  Mr. Grabski is said to have related that when the basement for his house was built, remains were found.  And, local lore indicates after he died, his ashes were spread around the monument across the street from his house.

Kate merriman

I am indebted to the Lake County Genealogical Society for their body of research on Lake County cemeteries (www.lcgsohio.org/cemeteries/madison-cemeteries/). Some of the information in this blog is based on local legend, and additional information/facts regarding the monument are welcome!

Submitted by Jesse Devin, Social Media Assistant Madison Historical Society

There are many ways to donate.
Discover which suits you best.

The Madison Historical Society is a 501(c)3 corporation, and most donations have tax advantages. You can support MHS through making a donation, shopping with Amazon Smile, a tax-free IRA Contribution, or a gift of Stock.

To make a General donation, Memorial donation, or Capital Fund Drive donation to the Madison Historical Society, please complete the form below and make a payment via PayPal using your credit card or PayPal account. If you prefer to send a check, please make it payable to Madison Historical Society and send to PO Box 515, Madison, OH 44057.

If you are making this donation as a General donation, Memorial or in Honor of donation, or Capital Fund Drive donation, please note that information here
If yes, please provide name and address of the individual to receive the acknowledgement letter:
Please note: When you click the "Continue to PayPal" button below, you will be directed to PayPal to complete your donation. Your donation is not complete until you finish the payment process with PayPal. Thank you for your donation

Volunteer

Volunteers created the Madison Historical Society in 1978, and have been essential to the success of our organization! We are always looking for people to help with a variety of activities that keep the society running smoothly. Why not share your enthusiasm, creativity, and talent with us?